Reflections on Rare Moments by Lowe

What does it mean to be prepared for “rare moments”? Recently, an inspiring article seized my attention with a memorable case for classical Christian education. Citing an English schoolmaster who strove to form men “acceptable at a dance and invaluable in a shipwreck,” she illustrates the true aim of classical Christian education. The author A well-educated person, the author argues, must be prepared for both civility and calamity—for “the shipwreck and the dance, the battlefield and the banquet hall.” Echoing this dual ideal of virtue, the piece then cites C.S. Lewis’s insight that this type of character does not happen accidentally, but “needs to be achieved.”

The author contrasts this vision with modern education’s emphasis on pragmatism and measurable outcomes. While academic success and college admissions matter, they are “by-products of an education that pursues the development of a soul.” True education, rooted in the classical Christian education tradition, aims at formation. This orders a student’s love toward what is True, Good, and Beautiful. When education pursues transcendent ends, earthly competence follows. Drawing on thinkers such as Aristotle, Augustine, and G.K. Chesterton, the article emphasizes that education must prepare students for the “rare moments” of life.

We cannot predict the future, but we can form students deeply enough that when those moments come, they know who they are, what they stand for, and how they are called to love and serve.

Classical Christian Education at Adolesco Prep

At Adolesco Prep, students are trained in this same spirit. Like the vision described below, Adolesco prioritizes formation over mere information. Through a rich engagement with Scripture, literature, and history, students are steeped in the language of virtue and heroism. They are taught not only to excel academically but to cultivate discipline, courage, humility, and eloquence.

The goal of classical Christian education at Adolesco is not simply impressive test scores (though those often follow), but young men and women prepared to lead, serve, and stand firm in both celebration and crisis. Students who can move seamlessly between refinement and resilience—graduates who are gracious in the “dance” and steadfast in the “shipwreck,” ready to perform the “definite service” God has prepared for them.

I’m sure you will enjoy this article as much as I did…

Rare Moments (by Leigh Lowe)

J.F. Roxburgh, Headmaster of the Stowe School in England in 1930, stated that the purpose of his institution was to produce men who were “acceptable at a dance and invaluable in a shipwreck.” This humorous quip conveys a truism about the purpose of a good education. Mr. Roxburgh suggests that a well-educated person should be able to move seamlessly between civility and calamity. With this general idea Roxburgh seems to be echoing the expectation of the ideal medieval knight whom Malory says is the “meekest man that ever ate in the hall and the sternest knight to thy mortal foe….” In his essay, The Necessity of Chivalry, C. S. Lewis also comments on this standard. He says: “The important thing about this ideal is, of course, the double demand it makes on human nature.” The perfect knight, he says, “is not a compromise or happy mean between ferocity and meekness; he is fierce to the nth and meek to the nth.” Lewis then tells us the important part that’s relevant to us: “The man who combines both characters … is a work not of nature but of art.” This dual identity is, he says, “…something that needs to be achieved, not something that can be relied upon to happen.”

Education is what makes this possible, and our attitude toward rare moments reveals how we think about education. According to both Roxburgh and Lewis, education should prepare a person for the polar moments in life—the extremes. The shipwreck and the dance. The battlefield and the banquet hall. I’d like to suggest that being prepared for and anticipating the rare moments of life is one of the characteristics that distinguishes  classical Christian education from modern education. It distinguishes a worldview focused on faith and transcendentals from a worldview focused merely on pragmatism or materialism. Like the perfect knight, we, too, understand as Christians that we are supposed to acknowledge our dual identities. We understand that we are in the world but not of it. We recognize that while we do have to meet the demands of earthly living, our hope hangs elsewhere. We, too, have a double demand on our nature. So how do we reconcile this? We look to Lewis to rescue us, and, of course, he does. He tells us plainly: “Aim at Heaven and you will get earth ‘thrown in’: aim at earth and you will get neither.”

Classical Christian education is about formation. Pursuing good ends habitually is what many of the great thinkers from Aristotle to Augustine to Cardinal Newman identified as the purpose of education—orienting our affections and ourselves toward what is True, Good, and Beautiful, and marching steadily toward those ends. We want students well-grounded in the essential and the eternal instead of the secondary and the temporary.

Memoria Press is thoughtful about every component in the curriculum because books form us in real and consequential ways. They inspire conviction and courage. The classics are ceaselessly relevant and eternally formative. That’s why they are classic. The curriculum teaches us what to pursue by giving us the best books, with the best lessons, by the best authors as judged by human history. The lessons needed for moral and intellectual growth are there in great repetition. We can see the virtues played out in countless examples. We can also see the consequences of sin over and over again. When writing about books, Lewis reminds us that we don’t have the time or circumstances to learn all of the lessons by individual experience, but education gives us this chance. And, hopefully, we are afforded a few victories and spared a few heartbreaks because of it. In pursuing good content, character is formed, and we are, consequently—hopefully—better prepared to answer our callings in the rare moments when they arrive.

If we are to defend civilization, we must be steeped in the language of literature, and history, and Scripture. We must build a home for heroes in our hearts so we can call them up when the enemy appears at the bridge. We hope and pray that we don’t find ourselves in conflict every day, but it’s unrealistic to expect that we will never find ourselves embattled. It is precisely in those rare moments, when we find ourselves unsettled or uncertain, that we need to know who we are, what we stand for, and how we are called to love and serve.

So, what do we prioritize—and more importantly, why? We should start by acknowledging the truth: We cannot anticipate the future. We can’t really predict what we will need to know in life or when we will need to know it. This helps us with our situation as educators. The solution to the apparent conflict between what we need to know and what we ought to know is realizing that there is no conflict at all. We simply have to properly order our goals. We accept reality and acknowledge that we do live on earth. We do want our students to have knowledge, skills, and abilities. We do want our students to have academic success and a world of opportunities after high school. We do care what students achieve. But we care even more about who they become.

Of course, standardized test scores and college acceptance rates are important—and in these areas our students earn impressive results—but as champions of classical Christian education we recognize these as the material ends of an education that seeks to achieve more. We consider these to be by-products of an education that pursues the development of a soul in pursuit of authentic happiness, of a student committed to becoming who God wants him or her to be, of a person willing and able to perform what Cardinal Newman calls the “definite service” God has committed to him or to her and to no one else. This is why educators should talk about character and wisdom and virtue as often as they do about grades and assignments and books. Education is about more than just careers and productivity. Students are made for more than their contribution to the GDP.

Modern education, with its emphasis on pragmatism, seems to bank on statistics, on tempting fate, and on predicting—if not hoping—that the rare moment will never come. But the truth is, as classical Christian educators, we don’t really care if the rare moments come or not. We are going to prepare for them anyway because we strive to prioritize what is transcendent and timeless instead of what is merely fashionable and fleeting.

G. K. Chesterton says of fads:

A fad or heresy is the exaltation of something which, even if true, is secondary or temporary in its nature against those things which are essential and eternal, those things which always prove themselves true in the long run. In short, it is the setting up of the mood against the mind.

As Christians we know that we will be asked to serve in ways we didn’t expect, to rise to an occasion we didn’t anticipate, or to face a calamity we couldn’t have predicted, so we approach education differently. We prepare broadly for a future we cannot see.

This is true for our students, but you might also be able to relate. You, reading in this moment, might be responding to your rare moment, when you are not where you expected to be. You might feel stretched out of your comfort zone, little pangs of doubt pestering you to consider if you are really ready to lead your school or teach your subject or educate your children. This year might offer you that rare moment when you are asked to move seamlessly from civility to calamity. You might be asked to be more courageous, more refined, more faithful, or more persuasive than you thought you could be. This might be the moment for which a broad education has prepared you to do something great.

Preparing for the rare moments means acknowledging an uncertain future. It means preparing for a special moment—even hoping for it—as we march steadfastly along with discipline and fortitude, trusting in a faithful God. In this way, we walk confidently into an unknown future because we just might need to be acceptable at a dance or invaluable in a shipwreck.

Want to Learn More About our Classical Christian Education?

If you are interested in learning how classical Christian education can form this quality of character in your child, Adolesco Prep hosts parent interest meetings. The final meeting to enroll in the 26-27 school year is March 10. Please fill out this short form, and we’ll send you all the necessary information.

Let’s discover how we can cultivate the extraordinary together.